Breakfast/Snacks/Sweet Treats/Vegetarian

New Recipe: Super Easy Coconut Yogurt

Super Easy Coconut Yogurt

New Recipe: Super Easy Coconut Yogurt

Super Easy Coconut Yogurt

We considered creating a coconut yogurt recipe involving pots and pans, temperature gauges, and a complicated method, but that’s really not our style. And we’re all busy. This Super Easy Coconut Yogurt is perfect – three ingredients*, two minutes preparation time and one tasty end result. We hope it satisfies your need, and if you’ve been buying store bought coconut yogurt, saves you a small fortune. This recipe costs less than $4 and makes 400g. (Just quietly, we actually can’t believe we ever paid $9.95 for that much yogurt, no matter how delicious it is!).

Ingredients

  • 1 x 400ml can full fat coconut cream
  • 1 probiotic capsule**
  • 1 tablespoon tapioca/arrowroot flour

Method

  1. Firstly, chill your coconut cream in the fridge. We usually pop mine in overnight, but a few hours will do.
  2. Combine coconut cream, powder from inside of probiotic capsule and tapioca in a sterilised jar. Stir well and seal the lid.
  3. Turn your oven light on and leave the jar in overnight. Do not turn the oven on. The heat from the light is sufficient to incubate the yogurt and allow it to thicken. The longer you leave it, the thicker it becomes.
  4. Remove from the oven and leave on the bench for another few hours. Store in the fridge for a week.
  5. Delicious with our Sugar Free Breakfast Cereal and just perfect with our 80s Chocolate Souffle. Enjoy.

*For a sweeter yogurt, add 1 tablespoon of rice malt syrup.

**We use Orthoplex Multiflora. Inner Health Plus will do, but we suggest you speak to your Naturopath or Pharmacist for a good quality, practitioner brand.

FAQs – Directions

  1. Oven light?! How do I turn it on?
    To turn your oven light on, you may need to turn the oven setting on and leave the temperature gauge at zero. This will depend on your specific oven of course.
  2. But my oven light is broken?
    Well get it fixed! Just kidding, this should work on a warmish day by simply leaving your sealed jar out for a day or two. Avoid direct sunlight – provided it’s not winter, the kitchen bench will do. Standard yogurt is made in exactly the same way, so please don’t worry about it being unrefrigerated as yogurt is technically “off” anyway.
  3. Mine turned out runny! What went wrong?
    Firstly, please check that you followed the method precisely. Do not use low-fat coconut cream. Secondly, be patient. It may just take an extra day to thicken, depending on your oven and how long you left it out for. Lastly, it is probably temperature and/or climate related, so check your oven, and when leaving it out on the bench, do so on a warmer day.
  4. Can I use my yogurt maker?
    We haven’t tried this method, but please give it a try and report back on how it went.

FAQs – Ingredients

  1. Do I have to use full fat coconut cream?
    Absolutely. Low-fat products belong in the bin. Read Fats: the truth! to learn more.
  2. What’s tapioca flour?
    It’s basically a gluten free starch. Tapioca and arrowroot are one and the same and can be purchased from the baking aisle of the supermarket. It acts to thicken the yogurt, but you can omit it. Please use the flour and not the pearls.
  3. Do I have to use tapioca flour?
    No. But it’s the easiest way to thicken in our opinion.
  4. Will chia seeds work instead?
    Kind of, but you end up with clumpy yogurt and it’s nothing like the original version.
  5. Can I use one batch of yogurt to get the next one started, or do I have to keep buying probiotic capsules?
    Yes, as long as you make it every 5-7 days to keep feeding the bacteria. If it tastes sour or stops becoming as thick, start again!

FAQs – Other

  1. Where do you buy your lovely jars?
    They’re mason jars my mjlso. Google will help.


99 thoughts on “New Recipe: Super Easy Coconut Yogurt

    1. Even if you turn the oven setting on, with the temperature on zero? Otherwise, leave it on the kitchen bench on a warm day – that should do the trick!

      1. Hiya! Thank you so much for sharing your wisdom! I successfully made coco yogo last night in the Easiyo yoghurt maker, using pretty much your recipe and method. I used potato resistant starch for the thickener (as it’s what I had in the cupboard, and also, bonus prebiotics!) – 2 heaped teaspoons for 1 x 400ml can of coconut cream, and 3 probiotic capsule contents. Mixed it in the tub then used hot tap water to fill the reservoir (not boiling water). Left it overnight. This morning it was thick and creamy and gorgeous! Thank you again!! 🙂

  1. Yep tried your original method. left it in the oven overnight and took it out and left it on the bench for 2 days in about 20 degrees room temperature and it’s turned out perfect! No tapioca required. Thanks!

  2. I tried this yesterday and used my Easiyo, but it didn’t thicken? It just tasted like coconut cream. I didn’t put the easiyo in the oven though! Any ideas what i did wrong?

      1. Doesn’t need the oven with the easiyo. See India’s post above. I followed that (though used the arrowroot) & had great coyo with no oven involved! Made at night, ready in the morning!

  3. What is the difference between creamed coconut and coconut cream?? I couldn’t find coconut cream in the store, but I have coconut milk and creamed coconut.

  4. Hi Steph, I made the coconut yogurt a couple of days ago and it’s fantastic! My only problem is it has a grainy texture (other than that you’d hardly know it isn’t coyo…and a less than a third of the price!) just wondering if you had any tips or tricks that would help me to get a smoother consistency next time? Thanks so much! You’re a great inspiration…

  5. Just put my coconut cream in the fridge. Can’t wait to try this out! I’m amazed by its simplicity! Other recipes call from thermometers and all sorts. Could you tell me the difference between tapioca and arrowroot? From what I’ve read they are both gluten free but I’m not sure if they can be used interchangeably throughout all recipes, whether they are the exact same thing, or whether they are similar and have different uses … help :/

      1. Steph, no they are not the same: Both are tropical root vegetables, but entirely different plants. Arrowroot starch comes from the Maranta arundinacea plant, which is considered an herb, while tapioca is obtained from the cassava root. Both are gluten free and popular thickeners. “While both arrowroot and tapioca are used to thicken sauces, soups and such, they are just different enough to make it important for your to know the differences so that you can use them for top results”. (source – see http://www.agirlworthsaving.net on arrowroot vs tapioca: what’s the difference? and other websites). Odile

  6. Hi! I absolutely love your recipes, thank you! I’ve been very excited to eat this yoghurt, but after 4 days (including 2 warm days) it’s still runny. Any ideas? I followed the recipe exactly, but only chilled the cream for 3 hours not overnight. The only other thing I could think of is that the probiotic tablets I bought are duds. I bought the Swisse ones the other day and took them straight home and popped them in the fridge. Any thoughts?

  7. Hi Steph, I love your work and you’ve inspired me to start studying Nutrition. I’ve tried this recipe a few times now and every time it comes out too runny. I followed every step very carefully. I’m using the Woolworth Macro brand organic coconut cream, the tapioca (I have tried making it 2 tablespoons and this still doesn’t work) I have also tried leaving it in the oven and on the bench for longer. I have also tried another version where you put the oven on low for 3hrs then switch it off and have a shorter oven time given the added heat, and nothing has worked….Any other suggestions? Would love to be able to make this successfully myself as I’m quite severly lactose intolerant and have been missing yogurt. Thanks in advance, Tanya

    1. Hi Tanya, you’re not alone with this one and the only thing I can suggest is that you try a few different coconut creams. I just made another double batch using a standard coconut cream and it is thick and delicious. Good luck!

  8. The first time I made the coconut yogurt, it turned out runny. The second time, I realized that there is a thick cream around the edges of the box that I had not scraped out and used. When I made sure all the coconut cream was being used, it worked. Also, make sure you use mason sealable jars. That made a difference too. It is so delicious. I mix it with cinnamon and monk fruit sweetener – The perfect dessert and it satisfies my sweet tooth.

  9. Hi,

    I tried making some of this, followed the ingredients, left it in the oven with the light on from 3pm to 7am the next day, then popped it in the fridge, forgot the instructions said to pop it on the bench. It tastes good, but it’s a bit too runny. I added an extra tbs of tapioca flour, and have left it on the kitchen bench. Should I pop it back in the oven for a few hours to help thicken?

  10. I made this using full fat coconut cream, put it in the oven overnight for 12hrs with the oven light on and it was very runny – like milk? I then left it on the bench for another 24hrs and it is still runny like milk… Any ideas on where I went wrong? Thanks in advance 🙂

  11. Hi,

    Could you help clarify a few things? When you say put the can in the fridge: do you mean you then scoop off the cream and discard any liquid or do you still use the entire contents? Also, you mentioned that you find the yogurt sweet enough just with the tapioca flour — does the tapioca sweeten it somehow? The tapioca flour I have (it is genuine tapioca) is similar to cornflour in texture as has a raw, floury taste — wouldn’t it need cooking? I’m yet to try your method. I’ve tried others but not had much success.

    1. Hi Flo, use the whole can. Tapioca is a carbohydrate, so it does provide a little sweetness surprisingly. Please try the recipe and I look forward to hearing what you think!

  12. I’m making this right now for the first time and discovered I also don’t have a light setting on my oven.
    The lowest temp it will go to is 30deg. Do you think might be too hot? Would it be best on the bench? It’s probably a 30deg day anyway! Ha ha

  13. Hi I am so keen to try this.. How would it go in a dehydrator? Also, I normally buy ayam brand coconut cream would this be suitable ?

    Thankyou 🙂

    1. Hi Melissa, you will need the oven light or a warm climate to thicken the cream. I do have a feeling the Ayam may not thicken as well as some brands. The brand “Asia Specialities” works a dream!

  14. I’ve been reading various coconut yogurt recipes today. Many have you heat the coconut milk or cream in a pan before doing anything else. Any idea why? Also why do you put the coconut cream in the fridge overnight if you are going to use the whole can and then put it in the oven (with light) or whatever method. Seems like an unnecessary step.

  15. Will this work with most regular types of coconut cream? Having searched high and low in my part of the world, I’m yet to find a brand that doesn’t include ingredients typical of the following, all of which contain Sodium Metabisulphite, some with sugar added too-
    Coconut Extract (68%), Water, Stabilisers (Guar Gum, Carboxymethylcellulose), Emulsifier (Polysorbate 60), Antioxidant (Sodium Metabisulphite) –
    To me, this doesn’t sound like a very hospitable environment for natural fermentation to take place.

  16. Hi Steph, what’s the reasoning behind chilling the coconut cream beforehand? Will it still work if you don’t?

    1. Hi Clare, it’s to help the thickness of the yoghurt, as some brands of coconut cream don’t end up creating the desired result. If yours isn’t thick, try a different brand first!

  17. Hi,

    I have followed your recipe and put it in the oven over night with the light on. This morning it had separated. So I shook it up again and place it back in the oven.

    Let’s see how it goes. Have you had this happen before?

  18. Would I be able to use a store bought coconut yogurt to start mine off instead of using probiotics or do I need to make a home made version first?

  19. alot of comments about the coconut cream but what about the probiotics. Do I have to buy a jar of pills to make this yogurt?

  20. Thanks Steph for your simple recipe. I have just made my first batch and thanks to the Aus. Summer it”ll just ‘brew’ up in the kitchen! Looking fwd to sum yum coco yogi tomorrow night!
    Bless ya for sharing your recipe!

  21. Hi Steph

    I’m about to make my first batch of coconut yoghurt and am going to use Nudi coconut yoghurt as the culture. How much should I use for say I tin of coconut cream.

    Cheers Melissa

  22. Hi Steph, I started my yoghurt yesterday, it is thickening up nicely. I notice it has a layer of clearer liquid in the bottom of the jar (about 1/2 cup), and the thick creamy yoghurt is on top (about 1 1/2 cups). Is that ok? Should I scoop off the thick yoghurt and tip out the liquid? Or should I stir it all together? I can’t wait to try it! Thanks so much for the recipe.

  23. hi what consistency is your coconut cream whine comes out i can only get coconut cream in either block form or in a carton that is like a heavy cream like consistency, i presume its not coconut milk you mean from a can?
    thank you.

  24. I’m onto my 6th batch and still ending up with a very runny end result. Have tried coconut cream, even refrigerated it. Tried tapioca and increased the probiotic capsules. Have tried leaving it on the bench, oven method and easiyo method. Still failing, any other suggestions to get it thick? I’m using the honest to goodness brand of coconut cream which is bpa free and no other nasties added. I should just give up I know but I can’t rest not knowing what I’m doing wrong.

    1. Hi Alison, you will need to try another brand of coconut cream. I have provided some more information within the recipe to assist.

  25. Hi, ive started to make this and have just realised ive used coconut milk. I chilled it in the fridge and it went quite thickish. Now have it in the oven. Will it still work this way with the milk?

  26. I started mine two days ago but it’s still runny , I wonder if it’s cause I left it in a Esky with hot water at night cause of my oven light ? I will try some of the comments reccomandation and hope it works …

  27. Just wondering if the cartons of Kara coconut cream are good to use? And a powdered yoghurt starter from local health food store ? Or a tub of coyo just bought from the supermarket?

  28. Hi I’ve had mine in my easiyo thermos overnight with hot water under the glass jar, and I removed it from easiyo this afternoon and Now it’s on my bench. It has a off clear colour layer at the bottoms looks like its split is that normal or has it turned bad? What would recommended

  29. Just came across this doing my usual Googling whilst eating my breakfast with store bought coconut yoghurt which always seems to be inconsistent in thickness. I personally adore the thicker version and reading the label on the store bought states milk as the ingredient so I presume starting with cream would result in a thicker creamier consistency.
    What type of consistency does your recipe result in. I am keen to try also but my oven too does not have even have a light as it is prehistoric like me.
    I wonder if putting it in the microwave with the oven door ajar would do the trick.

    1. Hi Tracy, this recipe works out thick and creamy with the right brand of coconut cream. If you live in a warm climate it will even work on the bench!

  30. This yoghurt making idea is leaving me baffled as until stumbling upon your site I never knew making yoghurt at home was so common.

    Having followed up with a substantial amount of time Googling what others do your method is the only one I have come across that states using chilled coconut cream. I had a go and split the difference using room temp coconut cream which was very un-creamy to begin with, added a tablespoon of arrowroot as well as a Swisse probiotic 35 billion fridge free capsule and fermented it in an Easiyo yoghurt maker. After about 15 hours it was in the same state as in the beginning.

    I would love to have another attempt but not sure what has caused the failure. Any ideas???? Please……

  31. I have now tried 2 batches, without much success, using easiyo method. 2nd time, I used Asia Specialties premium quality coconut cream (as suggested). I don’t understand why you have to chill coconut cream first, as it resulted in a solid lump of cream, which I could not mix with other ingredients. I tried as best as I could, but again without success. Any suggestions anyone?!
    Am determined to keep trying…:) Ha!

    1. Hi again Deb, the chilling is to thicken the cream but if you don’t feel like you need this due to using the easiyo method, then please leave this step out.

  32. Hi Steph, Thanks so much for your super easy coconut youhurt recipe. I didn’t use arrowroot and it turned out super thick. Just worried about the smell, though. Have to hold my nose to eat it. Is this normal? I forgot about it, so it stayed in my garage (the hottest part of my house) for 2 days and nights in our Queensland summer. It tastes ok, and I haven’t died yet, but?????
    Joan

    1. Hi Joan, in general fermentation time needs to be shortened in warmer climates. The smell does mean it’s bad though, it’s just the Saccharomyces bacteria growing more due to the heat. Next time, stick to an overnight ferment. Enjoy.

  33. Hi there! So after i did the whole process and put it in the fridge, all the fat from the coconut cream separated and rose to the top and the rest was still extremely runny :/ it tasted nice though….Anyone else with this issue?

  34. Hi there, I’ve only tried the recipe once. I figured it is pretty simple so should be ok, and with the successful comments from others. Alas…..I have doubled the quantities, 2 x cans of FF coconut cream, 2 vegan probiotic capsules and 2 tablespoons of tapioca. After 3 days in the oven with the light on the mix is still running, only slightly thicker than water in consistency. Is this normal, am I impatient because I’ve doubled the quantities do I need to wait longer?

    1. Hello Jason, it is important to use Ayam full fat coconut cream as your coconut cream. With the cooler weather the process will take longer, leave it for an extra day or two and see what the difference is. You may consider playing around with the amount of tapioca and see if that makes a difference, we have not tried doubling the recipe ourselves. Let us know how you go!

  35. Hi thanks for the tips. Not sure the winter will affect it as it is cold outside but warm inside 🙂
    Plus the oven is warm from the light.
    I left it in for 3 days this time and it did not set in the oven, but thickened once I’d put it in the fridge. It was very “tangy”. I’m not sure if that is normal. I am reluctant to add any sugar. Is the tangyness normal? Or should I only leave it in th oven for the 24 hours and then let it set in the fridge?
    Thx J

  36. Hi I have tried this with the tcc full coconut yogurt and it’s still runny. Was in the oven with light on for over 24 hours and on the bench for a further 24 hours. What cream should I use otherwise? I use the probiotic and tapioca flour

    1. Hello, as it is cooler at the moment we suggest leaving it for a day longer. If it is still runny, try using Nakula Coconut Cream which is available at good health food shops.

Leave a Reply to Alison Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

For weekly recipes, articles, performance tips and giveaways